Rock, Paper, Shotgun

Jack Keane Eurogamer Review

By John Walker on March 24th, 2008 at 11:22 am.

The new adventure from Deck 13, they behind the surprisingly lovely point and clicker Ankh… haven’t done it again. Jack Keane, developed in a similar manner, has sadly drowned beneath poor puzzle design and an absolutely attrocious translation. Hence my recent appeal.

Insert funny comment onto screenshot

My review is now up on Eurogamer, and it contains these words.

“Maybe it’s over-confidence. Maybe we celebrated Ankh’s not-awfulness too much. But Jack Keane is a depressingly poor game. A big, elaborate, beautifully drawn game. But one that just doesn’t make a satisfying result.”

Read the rest here.

__________________

« | »

, , , , .

4 Comments »

  1. malkav11 says:

    Hmm. That’s too bad.

    May I take it from your review that you share my failure to be impressed by Runaway: A Road Adventure, despite its warm critical reception in many corners?

    report

  2. At least the demo properly reflects the full thing then.

    *Use sandbag on thugs standing on Big Ben’s clockhands so bird on other side of screen flies away so cowardly protagonist can pick up his sodding knife again*

    report

Comment on this story

XHTML: Allowed code: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Search

Respond to our gibber

  • MadMatty : “haters gonna hate” on The Sunday Papers
  • nootpingu86 : “If we're going to use that word as a stand-in for awe-inspiring let's use it for a game that actually cares about verisimilitude and using ...” on The Sunday Papers
  • InternetBatman : “@Wizardry But Neverwinter Nights, which was also ATB solved a lot of those problems. Flanking and backstabbing still worked. Opportunity attacks were in there and ...” on Obsidian Want To Know What You Want Them To Make
  • jaheira : “Good post Sinderlin. Doesn't your argument that Valve have a moral requirement to tell us what's going on depend on your definition of promising? What ...” on The Sunday Papers
  • InternetBatman : “It seems like you're arguing that narrative content is bad (by reducing the dependence on game mechanics and making the game less freeform), that game ...” on Obsidian Want To Know What You Want Them To Make

Browse the archive