Systemic Shock: Maia’s Science And Stories

By Adam Smith on June 24th, 2013 at 9:31 pm.

At the first Rezzed, a year ago, I saw Maia for the first time. Back then, before the nail-biting Kickstarter campaign, what I was shown was more engine than game, an almost frighteningly impressive technical achievement, created by one person and almost tentatively shown to a few eager onlookers. A couple of days ago, I saw the game again. It isn’t finished but it was one of the most intriguing propositions at a show packed with variety.

I didn’t manage to see every presentation and panel at Rezzed because there were also games to play, people to talk to and coffee to drink, but the one that best set the tone of the event for me was hosted by our very own John of Walker. In theory, it was a discussion about storytelling in games, with a broad cast of characters – Ragnar ‘Dreamfall’ Tornquist, Dean ‘Day Z’ Hall, Will ‘ Zomboid’ Porter, Ed ‘Brink’ Stern and Chris ‘Everything Else’ Avellone.

The conversations that the audience heard, and that you can hear by listening below, gave an insight into the breadth of opinion and varied execution within the sphere of things that we call ‘game’. From the more traditional narratives, world-building and characterisation of Tornquist’s adventures and adventures, to what I think of as the collaborative storytelling of Day Z. Designers create systems and players, either in solitude or together, collaborate with those systems – and through them, the designer – to create dramas, comedies and tragedies, some spanning hours, others lasting for a matter of seconds.

I was pleased to hear Crusader Kings II mentioned, if only briefly, as it’s one of the strongest engines for narrative that I’ve ever encountered, but there was another game, one that actually made an appearance at Rezzed, that may well capture the beauty of systemic storytelling just as brilliantly. It’s no surprise that its name wasn’t spoken because it wasn’t on the show floor and hasn’t been released. The game is Maia, Simon Roth’s Kickstarted colonisation simulation, a game part sci-fi Dungeon Keeper and part Dwarf Fortress with a more usable UI and excellent graphics.

Accompanied by Paul Dean of Shut up and Sit Down and now lead writer on Roth’s project, I sat down to talk to Simon and watched as he demonstrated the incredible complexity of the world’s simulation. I use the word ‘incredible’ in its literal sense. This is a game with ecosystems, both flora and fauna acting and reacting, and with science in place of stats.

As I watched Simon construct the beginnings of a base, in caves that are protected from the violent and changeable weather that alternately bombards, burns and freezes the surface, he often hesitated as I asked about various occurrences and features. Eventually, I had to change my approach because I was looking for individual systems, wondering how health, happiness and diet were tracked and monitored, when I should have been looking at the entire simulation as one, extremely complex machine.

The doomed colonists begin their mission in an airlock, a group of chickens scratching around their feet, and can then begin the process of constructing a place to live and to work. Indeed, they live TO work. Like Sims and actual people, they have many needs to fulfil, and I asked Simon if those needs would include some sort of Fun Meter. Would they have recreation rooms, with pool tables and anti-grav chess/dance floors?

No, was the answer, they certainly wouldn’t. The colonists become unhappy if they don’t have any work to do and, thankfully, it takes a lot of work just to survive. Solar flares burn anyone foolish enough to wander outside without adequate protection. The night is as black as a good cup of coffee and without lights, people become afraid – even the I.M.P. robots can be afraid of the dark, with their intentionally rudimentary AI occasionally glitch. Most devastating of all, perhaps, are the meteors that crash into the surface. They’re capable of causing cave-ins, although this function, like many others, was disabled in the build I was shown.

Surviving is hard and it makes sense that the poor bastards stuck down there, carving out science labs, medical bays and radioactive chambers from the walls, aren’t particularly interested in hanging out at the bar. They are happiest when they’re working, and anxious when there is now work to be done, because to be idle is to invite death in one of its many guises.

So where are the health bars and the hunger bars? Hovering the cursor over a person reveals a great deal of data, but not in the form of percentages or any other abstract indicator. Instead, in sick-green seventies computer print-out fashion, a string of text stutters out of the cursor itself, listing the subject’s temperature and perspiration rate among other things. It’s a detailed medical report and as the little fellows run around the place, each individual component can be affected by exposure to the elements, by exertion, or by injury, dehydration and hunger.

Unlike Sims, they can’t be directly controlled. Tasks are set and they complete them in a sequence decided by the simulation. Everything is decided by the simulation. A hungry colonist will be more inclined to kill a chicken, or to collect its eggs, or maybe to harvest plant life by building a hydroponics centre. The player sets up a build queue, choosing the locations and size of facilities and machinery, but the colonists themselves decide when and how to tackle the tasks.

I probably spent an hour with Maia, being guided through the intricacies of the systems, but I could have spent an entire day watching the world at play, even though the actual progression, from barren wasteland to underground mega-facility, is currently lacking structure. The simulation itself is fascinating in its complexity and its ability to support ecosystems and biological functions is tremendously exciting.

At the moment, there are problems – not from lack of care but because some issues aren’t worth fixing until necessary. My favourite of all those Simon mentioned in passing is the fact that living creatures, including humans, will eat one another if no conventional food is available. Strand a human from all plant and animal life, remove all rations and trap the blighter in a room, and he’ll eventually start to eat himself. On a purely systemic level it makes sense, as does everything that’s happening.

Finding the balance will be a huge challenge, both from the design perspective and for players once they have their hands on the game, but the beauty of a game that is built around one enormous interlocking simulation of this type is that tweaking and changing it shows immediate results. Simon is also avoiding science fiction, or even game fiction – at a base level, everything in Maia is driven by energy. Actions expend energy and plants store energy, their capacity increasing as they grow. To power the machines in the base, more energy is needed, initially gathered by wind turbines, which react to the changing weather, meaning that if the wind dies down and there are no alternate sources of power, lights will flicked and eventually fail. Turrets will shut down, permitting the more unpleasant denizens of the cave to infiltrate. A bulkhead door may lock, trapping colonists on the wrong side of a lava flow. Or worse, allowing both the explorers and the lava back through the door, the former reduced to bones and ash, the latter bubbling through the base, burning as it goes.

And that brings us full circle, back to storytelling. Maia is capable of making stories even now, in an unfinished state, and it has a larger story as well, a narrative of alternate history, an impossible exploration of a distant planet with technology that is decades behind what we now possess. The game makes you believe it is possible though, even though the doors speak apparent gibberish, and the computers are primitive, with a flickering Nostromo-like glare.

The smaller stories, the ones that arise from that collaboration between player, system and designer, will be the main product of Maia’s ingenious construction. Even as I watched, knowing that there were no creatures lurking in the dark, when a generator failed and I could see the energy draining from its cells, I felt a sense of apprehension. On a workdesk, a table lamp flickered and died. Simon pointed out that even a source so small cast actual light, reflecting, illuminating anything that passed by, leaving a blank in the world when it was gone.

If the devil really is in the details, then Maia is destined to be a far more monstrous offering than Dungeon Keeper ever was. And I can’t wait to see what stories it has to tell.

__________________

« | »

, , , , , .

35 Comments »

  1. Tiax says:

    I am so freakin’ glad I backed this.

    • squirrelrampage says:

      Seconded!
      I am very happy to see that in this case, the words “simulation” and “procedual generation” actually mean something beyond the usual PR speak. Can’t wait for my copy to arrive.

    • shagohad says:

      the only game I have seriously considered backing, unfortunately I am a broke ass student and cant will have to wait :)

      glad his work is going well

    • rawrty says:

      My sentiment exactly. I’ve backed Wasteland 2, Sir, you are being hunted, and this. I’m glad I backed all of them, but I’m most excited for this one and really glad Simon got the money he needed to do this.

    • adamsorkin says:

      Me too. I’ve been waiting for something like this for a long time.

  2. captain nemo says:

    Excellent. Will keep an eye on this ambitious project.

    Though hearing descriptions of a ‘simulated eco-system’ reminds me of the early days of the S.T.A.L.K.E.R development.

    • Rindan says:

      Eh. If this game is as bad STALKER, one of my favorite games of all times, I’ll shed no tears, ecology be damned.

  3. Icarus says:

    Wow, this looks like one to watch. Can’t say I ever heard of it before now but looking forward to more coverage.

  4. lordcooper says:

    Lock me in a room for long enough and I’d probably eat part of myself too. Sounds more like a feature than a bug.

  5. rustybroomhandle says:

    But wait, according to David Braben, nobody does procedural generation any more, and according to Petey Molyneux nobody does god-games any more. So I conclude that this game is a mere figment of our imaginations.

    • ffordesoon says:

      It sure as shit sounds like a glorious dream.

    • tigerfort says:

      But according to numerous blatherers on the internet, no-one uses their imagination anymore, so it can’t even be that.

    • bluebomberman says:

      That snark is undeserved.

      You do realize this project nearly failed its Kickstarter?

      • The Random One says:

        Why don’t David Braben and Peter Molyneux deserve this snark?

        • shagohad says:

          yeah and it will be interesting to see what a full studio under Molenyeuex does with Godus, versus Simons team here :)

          • Sparkasaurusmex says:

            Would you rather play a game or be somebody’s lottery prize?

      • rustybroomhandle says:

        I’d say the fact that this nearly failed its Kickstarter is even more reason to snark.

  6. Spoon Of Doom says:

    I’m a backer, but I haven’t had time to play the alpha yet. I guess I really should do that.

    • Leb says:

      I’m a backer too but I’m refraining from touching it until it is more feature complete …. I want to experience the mystery of the first play through all together

      • rawrty says:

        Yeah I’ve been debating trying it but have been holding out for this reason as well.

      • Spoon Of Doom says:

        That thought crossed my mind as well. I’ve almost ruined Project Zomboid for me this way – played a rather early build a couple of times, and now I can’t get myself to play the game anymore even though from what I’ve been seeing and reading, it has vastly improved and amassed a lot more content since then. Sometimes it really is better to wait for a more complete version of a game.

      • Vesuvius says:

        I’m in the same boat- it’s also part of why I’ve held off on Prison Architect so far.

      • Synesthesia says:

        Yep! Exactly the same reason i dived into kerbal space program, had the time of my life for almost 30 hours, then closed, not to open it again for long time.

    • Belsameth says:

      It is currently, mostly, an engine test. I expect the AI to be enabled any build now tho, since the Rezzed build had it working (and nearly killed Simon :p )

      Oh, you can find him on quakenet often, to distract him from work with questions. The channel is #maiagame.

  7. MadJax says:

    I backed it, and gave Simon Roth my 2 spare weekend passes at the drinks for him and his girlfriend (Admittedly without realising it until he handed me a Maia wristband in exchange) Just a shame I didn’t get a chance to bump into him yesterday as he offered to show me the latest build :(

  8. Arkh says:

    I hope he opens pre-orders soon because I missed the KS but I want to play this game so much.

  9. Niko says:

    “The colonists become unhappy if they don’t have any work”. Jeremiah Fink approves.

  10. Superpat says:

    “My favourite of all those Simon mentioned in passing is the fact that living creatures, including humans, will eat one another if no conventional food is available. Strand a human from all plant and animal life, remove all rations and trap the blighter in a room, and he’ll eventually start to eat himself. On a purely systemic level it makes sense, as does everything that’s happening.”

    He really should make that a feature XD

  11. DonJefe says:

    Sounds positively lovely. Can’t wait.

  12. Synesthesia says:

    GAWD yes. This is exactly what i want. Can’t wait to get my hands on it. Cover clockwork empires sometime! That also looks VERY promising in it’s interlocking simulation shenanigans.

  13. JudyCrews37 says:

    Maria. although Eva`s bl0g is super, last thursday I got themselves a Toyota from having earned $8195 this munth and in excess of ten k this past-month. it’s definitly the best work I’ve had. I started this 7-months ago and immediately got me at least $82 per-hour. I use the details on this website, BOW6.COM

  14. zaik says:

    …so it’s basically like space Dwarf Fortress?

    sounds neat.

  15. Bart Stewart says:

    BioShock: Infinite designer Tynan Sylvester recently wrote on Gamasutra that game developers should abandon trying to create deep simulations.

    To paraphrase his “Simulation Dream” article (http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/TynanSylvester/20130602/193462/), the only thing that matters is what players perceive. That illusion of depth can usually be achieved more inexpensively and effectively with hints and facades; actually simulating systems is usually undesirable design.

    That idea — which was well-received even here on RPS when linked in a Sunday Papers — would seem to be directly contradicted by this description of Maia.

  16. hjd_uk says:

    Its seems like a polished, sci-fi Dwarf Fortress ( expecially with the more grisly aspects – although a Dorf wouldn’t resort to auto-canibalisation :) ) – and that is in no way a put-down, its looks great.

  17. SuperNashwanPower says:

    Maia-hee
    Maia-hoo
    Maia-hee
    Maia-HA-HA