Wot I Think: The Yawhg

By Alec Meer on February 28th, 2014 at 3:00 pm.

The Yawhg is a one-to-four player adventure game, by Damian Sommer and Emily Carroll, in which you try to direct the fate of characters plucked straight from a fairy tale that never was. It’s been out for almost a year, and also arrived on Steam yesterday.

In six weeks, something terrible is going to happen. The characters you play as don’t know this, but you do. And so you guide their lives, and their destinies, with that knowledge, trying to build them into people who can make the most of what’s left after the disaster. All of this has happened before, and will happen again. But hey, maybe you’ll be a doctor rather than the town drunk this time around.

It’s Choose Your Own Adventure as an open-ended fairy tale, where the enjoyment stems more from seeing what the game’s random event generator chucks at you than from trying to min-max your way to a happier ending. Heading off to chop wood in the forest in one turn, for istance, might result in a deadly tussle with a wolf and the loss of a few points from your Physique stat. Come the next turn, the whole werewolf thing happens and you wind up trashing whichever location you’re currently in. Or perhaps you never ran into the wolf – instead you were approached by a pack of talking rats who wanted your input on their upcoming election.

The ideal situation there, perhaps, is that you turn to the people you’re with and hoot ‘oh wow, I got the talking rats! Who do I choose to be their leader, the warlike one or the wise one?’ and the other one-to-three players all chime in with suggestions, as everyone ambiently co-operates to create a playful, meandering, frequently silly but sometimes bittersweet story. It’s a patchwork fairy tale, different every time.

I must avoid spoilers of course, although this is an odd situation as the reckoning in question is core to what’s basically a ten-minute game, played repeatedly. I.e. if you choose to play The Yawhg, you’ll encounter this event within less time than it takes to read this article. But there is a reckoning, and what you’ve done and been subjected to, and what stats you’ve built (or lost) in the preceding six weeks/turns affects what happens afterwards.

Now just wait a cockameme minute. Did I mention multiplayer? I did, yes. But I have not really played The Yawhg as a multiplayer game. Only the once, and that was with someone who couldn’t see the point. It is a singleplayer game too, but I can see, with only a slight degree of sadness that I’ve not been able to experience it as such, that it would come that much more alive if played in company. There’s no networking – two to four people sit around a screen/keyboard/gamepad and direct/narrate a fantastical story together, while very gently competing to see who winds up with the ‘best’ character. As a single player game, the lone Billy No Mates (hello!) can control a minimum of two and a maximum of four characters, free to pursue harmony or horror as he or she sees fit.

This creates two very different possible experiences. Played alone, I had an introspective experience, affected by the spectral folk soundtrack and the alternating optimism and tragedy of the random events. Then I saw this video, and how different the Yawhg is as a call-and-response multiplayer game, everyone bouncing off each other and hooting in glee/horror at each twist:

Even aside from the fact that the people in that video are rather more, er, demonstrative than I, the concept of someone reading the lines aloud totally transforms the game – taking it away from the stat-chasing and the worrying about consequences, and into an amateur dramatics party game. As a single player game, the Yawhg has an extremely limited lifespan – even with the random acts of cruelty or fortune, it’s not exactly challenging to reach a ‘good’ ending. Busting it out with a few semi-inebriated friends will be a different matter: ‘oh my god, you got the magical sores!’ or ‘you bastard, you’ve trashed the magic tower!’ and so forth.

Though, of course, there’s the local multiplayer game curse of not too many people realistically having their PCs hooked up to a big TV, and everyone clustering around a monitor making for an awkward form of socialising (I know, I know – an HDMI cable is cheap and easy, but that doesn’t mean it happens too often). There’s so much invention happening in local multiplayer, but by God games that do it are massively restricting their audience for this reason.

Me, I’ve experienced it as sombre, pretty, genteel thing with a clear edge of optimism even as everything turns to hell. It’s a game where the hand drawn art and ethereal, acoustic music are of at least equal importance to the unashamedly simple ‘game’ element, working together to build an affecting fairy tale feel, a strong sense of strange place from long ago, protecting The Yawhg from being simply a roulette wheel. I pictured a place, I pictured myself there – quaffing potions of unknown origin, brawling with drunkards, talking ghosts out of haunting hospitals, driving a lute player into despair, growing a magic beanstalk… And then trying to be something, anything, in the wake of the Yawhg. There might not be much to it, but it got me. For a time, at least.

But if the prettiness doesn’t grab you, I’m not sure what I can tell you here. Take away all surface, and what you’re left with is a very simple and repetitive game that plucks an image and a handful of text from its fairly slim database every time you choose an option.

Or, should I say, take away all heart and soul, and what you’re left with is a very simple and repetitive game that plucks an image and a handful of text from its fairly slim database every time you choose an option.

But you do have heart and soul, don’t you?

The Yawhg is out now.

, , .

16 Comments »

Sponsored links by Taboola
  1. Choca says:

    Also, you should really listen to then buy the excellent soundtrack found here : http://dualryan.bandcamp.com/album/the-yawhg-ep

  2. Premium User Badge

    Zallgrin says:

    I bought this game on launch (before it even got on Steam) and 15 bucks felt a bit too much for such a really short game. But still, it stuck with me and I have replayed it many times.

    And yes, the soundtrack is amazing as is the art. Some of the twists are really surprising and for God’s sake, don’t try to min-max this game. It’s much more interesting when everything goes to hell.

    • Choca says:

      On one of my playthroughs, The Yawhg was the least of the town’s problems, I had demolished three buildings by myself before week four.

  3. Premium User Badge

    strangeloup says:

    It makes me think both of Monster Loves You (to which it seems most similar, albeit a little more abridged) and King of Dragon Pass, both of which I’m really rather fond of. Could someone who’s played it say if The Yawhg compares favourably with either title?

    • StranaMente says:

      It’s quite similar to Monsters love you, in that it’s a Choose your own adventure kind of game, but it’s shorter. Even if short the game is nice, and as Alec pointed out, it’s both enjoyable as single and multiplayer even if in different ways.

  4. NeutronSoup says:

    For those who have played it, what would you say an appropriate age-level would be for players? Something that one could play with young kids/pre-teens, or more for the grown-ups?

    • Premium User Badge

      Zallgrin says:

      Yawhg does not have explicit sex or violence, but it’s has kind of muddy morals. Children up from 12 should be fine, but the question is whether they’d enjoy it.

      It’s unconventional, a bit weird and certainly not a black-and-white fairytale. Sometimes Yawhg is very sweet, but sometimes the repercussions are unexpectedly harsh. It does not have shocking content, but it can be upsetting and disappointing if you want a good nice ol’ fairytale.

      But it’s also very charming and kind in its own way. I suppose it all depends on the kids and what type of stories they enjoy.

  5. djbriandamage says:

    It’s a schizophrenic single player game or a local co-op board game, really, and these are wonderful things that fill a void. It’s something unique and special.

    I’d love to see this thing played over Skype or Twitch. Native multiplayer would have been nice but playing in front of an internet audience would be a really nifty experience.

    Do play this thing!

  6. Premium User Badge

    Morlock says:

    Watched the Idle Thumbs crew play it on twitch. The Yahwg looks like a unique, interesting experience, but I wonder how replayable it really is. After watching one game I don’t feel like I want to play it myself.

    • junsumoney says:

      It’s not very replayable. I pretty much experienced most that I could (very hard to find everything due to random events) in an hour, and got bored trying to find more. And the ending for each playthrough is not very remarkable. You’d think it’s a reflection of all your characters’ choices, but it’s really checking stats number and seeing if it matches the threshold for success.

      • Kitsunin says:

        That’s massively disappointing. It sounds like in general there’s just kind of not enough there, but I was hoping there would at least be a Princess Maker style ending with all these stats and an ending after x days.

  7. Pazguato says:

    What a shame! The game looks soooo good :'( Maybe the artist should find another team.

  8. Pich says:

    Is it just me or does Yawhg sounds like an yiddish insult?

  9. Junon says:

    Wow, I just listened to the EP… And for the second time I am buying a game more as sort of a companion piece or interactive music video to the soundtrack itself than strictly for the game.

    The first time was Hotline Miami, fwiw.

  10. MOKKA says:

    I think it’s best to threat the Yawhg like a boardgame. Invite some friends, get something to eat/drink, play a few rounds and have a good time.
    I played it alone for a bit, but stopped, because I didn’t want to experience everything it had to offer on my own.

  11. Tomatoboxer says:

    I have played it with two other friends huddled around a laptop, and can attest that it is excellent if you have other people around who are willing to get into the spirit of things.