Results 2,201 to 2,220 of 2928
Thread: What book are you reading?
14-07-2014, 05:52 AM #2201
So, I bought and finished THE LAST WISH (the Witcher one).
I enjoyed it, but I found it a slightly weird experience. I can't quite decide if it was good or bad. I think it was both. It seemed rather variable in terms of quality (both the stories, the characters and the translation). I can't really say how much of that is down to the translation, but it can't all be.
I thought the beginning was a bit weak, both in terms of ideas and translation.
Then I rather liked the middle.. I quite liked the structure of having short story "episodes" woven through a longer one. It made it less of a long slog and more digestible than many epic fantasy novels.
Then the ending seemed a bit weak again (both in terms of story and translation).
It didn't seem that the translation was bad exactly, the english seemed fine. But the style/delivery was a bit odd. It often seemed as if the punchline got delivered too early / before the joke. Or as if the characters were a bit ADD at times and couldn't focus on one topic.
The Geralt character also seemed to vary between being a very experienced bad-ass who could calmly respond to anything thrown at him, and a kind of naive newbie. A few other characters got thrown in with very little introduction.
Still, it interested me enough in the world and the characters that I really fancy playing the game now, and I might also pick up the later books.
PS, the titular "last wish" was at the same time rather clever and also an anti-climax due to the delivery. Again they just kinda let the punchline slip indirectly in the middle of something and then mostly ignored it.
14-07-2014, 02:44 PM #2202
I finally bought all of the A Song of Ice and Fire books. It's been a long time since I last read this much of a book in a single weekend. It does help that I've watched most of the series, so it's easier to comprehend who all the different characters are. I imagine it could be quite difficult to keep track of them all if you've never watched the series.
14-07-2014, 11:37 PM #2203
I was definitely confused for most of the first Song of Ice and Fire book, and a fair bit of the second. But at some point it all clicked.
I've rather enjoyed the TV show, because while I remember the main points of the books, I've forgotten a lot of the little complexities and details. So the TV show works quite well to remind me of those details, and also to clear up any bits that i'd missed.
Even the last 2 books, which weren't as well received, I still read through each in short order.
15-07-2014, 03:51 AM #2204
It also doesn't help that, at any given time, there tend to be three or more major storylines with completely disjoint casts of characters and very little cross-referencing, so you basically need to load a new cache line every other chapter.
Honestly, I never really had a problem keeping track of what is going on (although, I DID have to look up characters in later books to see if they were in earlier ones), but a good tip might be one I read for people who want to actually read Malazan: Keep a pad of paper nearby and jot down a quick detail of any character you "meet". Even if it isn't an important detail, it associates them with something in your mind and does a good job of keeping track.
15-07-2014, 04:19 AM #2205
He just has a much BIGGER ensemble cast than most, and you never know who's going to turn out to be important, or turn up again later, or who might seem important but be forgotten. Actually, come to think of it, it was only really the first book where I had trouble, and that was because as well as lots of people being introduced at a high rate, you were also learning the world, houses, politics, law, gods, etc..
The later books still introduce and manage a large cast, but by then we've at least got most of the world down.
I still maintain that whoever gets credited in the later books for the stupendously dumb idea to split them geographically was very very wrong. It means that as well as trying to keep track of everything else that's going on, we have the confusing chronology to deal with as well. (Plus it messes up half the momentum etc..)
15-07-2014, 04:33 AM #2206
After the first book, you know the main players and are largely set. And by the last two (the ones people didn't like as much), you get a feel for who is important and who isn't and just tune out the unimportant ones, which goes a long way toward making the books seem "bad".
And Erikson (Malazan) has him beat, with massive casts in each book AND new books with almost no shared cast with the previous ones. One day I WILL read that series, but I will likely need to wait until I find a good note taking app for my tablet so that I can record characters as I meet them :p
15-07-2014, 05:41 PM #2207
Alternatively, if you need a refresher on a character's history or prior appearances, the dedicated Wikis have character pages with book to book summaries. Just be careful of scrolling too far down... or accidentally seeing the date of their death on the right hand side. The pages aren't spoiler free, but you can see what this guy did in book 1 without spoiling what he does in book 4, with some careful scrolling and averting of the eyes.
To be fair though, you shouldn't have too much of an issue keeping track of all but the most minor of characters once you're a book or so in... They aren't just family trees with fantastic names, they're all reasonably distinct (except where they're not meant to be), they have their own character and voice, and (spoiler) they keep dying and can eventually be forgotten. Also, when a minor character from book 1 or 2 starts to have a more prominent role in book 4 or 5, there'll usually be a brief reintroduction to them, nothing too overt, but enough to remind you of what's come before.
Having watched the series will definitely help, but people were getting on fine with the books long before the show came along... don't worry too much about losing track and it'll all come together in the end.
15-07-2014, 06:00 PM #2208
And, if you have issues with ASoIaF and how big/sprawling it is, you'll have even more with the Malazan... Martin will hold your hand a little, Erikson twists that hand behind your back, pushes you forward and kicks you off a cliff.
16-07-2014, 03:14 AM #2209
16-07-2014, 08:06 AM #2210
17-07-2014, 01:51 AM #2211
Whereas Lord of the Rings is two (and a half) giant road trips where they are ALWAYS traveling and seeing new places.
If memory serves, Sanderson recently explained in an interview that one epic fight scene in his latest Stormlight Archives book was more about reminding people how huge the land was (for future books) than JUST being an epic battle that traversed the better part of a continent for Reasons.
23-07-2014, 03:48 AM #2212
Finished Abercrombie's "Half a King"
Yeah... Joe Abercrombie writing a young adult novel is sort of like letting a guy best known for "Johnny the Homicidal Maniac" make a children's tv show.
That being said, I loved it. It is definitely dark as hell and an Abercrombie book (a teenager talking about drowning a kingdom in rivers of blood...) and you can't help but think the world is a MUCH worse place for the events of the story having happened. But it also hits all the notes a YA book should hit: A young child is uncertain, events happen, he/she becomes a stronger and more mature person for it, and there is even a love interest arc. It is ALSO ridiculously bloody and horrific at times, so yay. And honestly, it has a lot of good morals and what not and encourages you to think about the consequences of actions.
To compare it to one of the most well known YA books of all time: Ender's Game is the kind of book that you love as a kid and later realize is full of HORRIBLE lessons and what not. Whereas Half a King is the kind of book you fully acknowledge is fucked up while you are reading it, but you later acknowledge it actually is really good.
23-07-2014, 04:09 AM #2213
- Join Date
- Jun 2011
aaaa, it's out?! It took me a while to warm up to Abercrombie, but I'm gonna get it as soon as I'm at a bookshop again :) Good year for books, so far...
23-07-2014, 11:18 AM #2214
23-07-2014, 12:04 PM #2215
I'm reading Nuclear 2.0: Why a Green Future Needs Nuclear Power, by Mark Lynas. Very interesting book, does challenge some of the established givens in environmentalism about the nuclear issue. As essential as renewable energy sources are, it does seem crazy to ignore the potential benefits of a super-low-emissions energy source like nuclear. This book approaches it in a pretty good level headed and balanced way.
25-07-2014, 04:54 AM #2216
Reading misspent youth by Peter f Hamilton. Its alright.....
It lacks the grandiose of his other book. Way too many boring teen angst by teen. Have hopes for a t as I'm only 100 pages in
The funniest thing is how the book aged even tough it was written on 2002. Little things really. Such as in 2010
copyright was abolished cause of internet which became data sphere. Didn't explain why tough. Just that information storage became very good.
Or term like real time link. So Skype and Dropbox and video stream?
25-07-2014, 09:29 AM #2217
- Join Date
- Jun 2011
As for what I'm reading, I'm about 50 pages into The Causal Angel. Whilst it's emphatically not something he'd do, I find myself wishing for a previously on simply to keep it all straight in my head between books. In his own way, Hannu does catch the reader up, but I can't help but feel I'm missing some important details due to not having read the books one immediately after the other and having them fresh in my memory.
25-07-2014, 10:29 AM #2218
Had my first legal vacation in 20+ years, so I spent two weeks reading some 35-40 Star Wars novels (and watering plants)...
After reading the Republic Commando and Thrawn series a while back, I decided to start from the beginning of the time line and most of the novels were actually quite decent until I got to the point where Anakin appears. Then things, as expected, went quite downhill, partly because of all the repetition, but also because it's not accurate repetition, some details are different in each book that repeats events, and that sort of makes it even more annoying.
And there's Jar Jar, of course. And Anakin.
My vacation ended, but I suspect my reading would have slowed down massively anyway; it gets rather tedious to read the same stuff over and over, and I don't know which novels could be skipped.
Sort of tempted to just ignore everything to do with the movies, but even that is a bit hard to determine (if I'd done that, I would have missed a couple of Darth Maul novels that were actually decent).
25-07-2014, 10:51 AM #2219
Stick to the stuff related to the OT I'd say.
25-07-2014, 11:51 AM #2220