Skyrim (Surprise.) I so badly wanted to love this game, to have a immersive open world. But somehow...the magic just isn't there, this time. Maybe I've just left these "emergent gameplay" games behind. I like to think not, but perhaps it is so.
STALKER. I so badly wanted to love this. Maybe its just the age of the thing. I tried. I really did.
Crysis. I loved this game - until the aliens show up. Before that point it was one of the best shooters I had ever played (just played it recently, the first time ever.) Amazing game. Then...well, you know, the aliens. Went downhill fast. Easily worth the $4.99 on Amazon nonetheless.