Rock, Paper, Shotgun

Posts Tagged ‘Bulletstormgate’

Bulletstormgate: Weichman Clarifies Position

By John Walker on February 23rd, 2011.

But will Fox News ever respond to our interview request?

I’m very pleased to say we’ve heard back from the last of the experts we contacted after the Fox News Debacle. We’ve now spoken to Jerry Weichman, Ph.D who was quoted by John Brandon as warning that games such as Bulletstorm could do serious damage to children, as an example of an expert who was “worried that video game violence may be reaching a fever pitch.” And while Weichman explains that he was not misquoted, he certainly has far more moderate views on videogames than someone reading the article may have believed. When calculating the rather odd maths that led to Brandon’s “nearly universally” angry experts, we counted Weichman amongst the two who were actually against the game. This was incorrect, as our interview with the clinical psychologist reveals, in which he explains, “there is nothing wrong with the game being produced and sold to the users it is intended for.” And we also learn that Dr Weichman is rather partial to a game of Call Of Duty.

Read the rest of this entry »

, , , .

85 Comments »

Bulletstormgate: Fox News Responds

By John Walker on February 21st, 2011.

And on and on and on, so long as the nonsense comes.

There’s always a twist. If you followed the Fox News Debacle, you’ll have seen the tale that began with an article on Rupert Murdoch’s esteemed news source that asked whether Bulletstorm was “the worst video game in the world”, and argued that playing it could cause people to rape. We took a closer look at the claims made, found that at least one of those interviewed had been deliberately misrepresented and another ignored, and demonstrated that the author of the article did not complete even basic fact checking before publishing (for instance, being willing to let readers believe that reported rapes are on the increase). Then the “expert” who triggered it all, Dr. Carole Lieberman, got in touch to finally provide her evidence for the “thousands” of articles that proved sexual violence in games causes sexual violence in real life. Nothing she sent had anything to do with the subject, and it became clear that she had either not read the papers she was linking to, or wasn’t able to understand them.

Now the original author of the Fox News article, John Brandon, has filed a new Bulletstorm story on FoxNews.com, in which he once again makes extraordinarily inaccurate statements that he cannot evidence, and decides to insinuate that Rock, Paper, Shotgun has not told you the truth. Oddly enough, we have.

Read the rest of this entry »

, , , .

235 Comments »

Respond to our gibber

  • MellowKrogoth : “Unfortunately, it's gonna get shut down by the copyright holders like all other LOTR total conversion that reached any level of significance and popularity. What ...” on Impressions: LOTR War In The North
  • Shooop : “One of the people from Techland is on the Steam forums taking questions about the game and people have brought up FOV a few times. ...” on Wot I Think: Call Of Juarez – Gunslinger
  • Shooop : “Oh and good news on top of all this, no U-play. But it does however use Steamworks. So maybe bad news for anyone who wants ...” on Wot I Think: Call Of Juarez – Gunslinger
  • Drinking with Skeletons : “Slow leveling is the real bane of ARPGs in my opinion. Borderlands 1 & 2 and Titan Quest had engaging systems, but I always hated ...” on Hands On: Grim Dawn
  • P7uen : “That's the only pun you guys can pick? I expected them to be coming in spades.” on A Minecraft Mod To Admeier: CivCraft

Read our finest words

Hands On: Grim Dawn

Search for clues

Browse the archive