The sort of thing I’d normally put in the Sunday Papers, but when I saw Soren Johnson twitter it this morning I think it’s worth linking by itself, especially because it deals with a lot of topics which have been floating around the RPS comments threads (and the inside of my head) recently. It’s Greg Costikyan notes from his presentation at GDC Austin, splendidly entitled Randomness: Blight Or Bane. This is the sort of thing I love seeing Costikyan do – a large, sweeping, cultural history of the topic which grasps and tackles the seeming paradox that we’re dismissive of randomness yet it’s persisted and thrived in gaming culture. One of Costikyan’s many strengths here is examining that innocuous “we”.
Rock, Paper, Shotgun
Posts Tagged ‘Greg Costikyan’
Costikyan On Randomness: Dice Or Die?
By Kieron Gillen on September 28th, 2009.
PC Gamer Goes To War
By Alec Meer on March 10th, 2008.
PC Gamer’s Tim Edwards, a top-chum and occasional employer of the RPS hivemind, wasn’t terribly happy about Greg Costikyan’s controversial assertion that a game review is a different, lesser beast to game criticism – a nobler species Costikyan claims barely exists. So he’s posted a riposte on the PC Gamer blog.
It includes stuff like this:
Greg’s is a purely semantic argument based around trying to define what reviews and criticism should be, that doesn’t take into account what reviewers and critics are already doing. Games criticism doesn’t /have to be anything/. There are no rules of what reviews can and cannot include – the only question for writers should be: what will the reader gain from the review?
There may be blood. There already is in the Gamer blog’s comments threads, in fact – but you lot will, I’m sure, keep it civilized over here.
Which side of the argument am I on? Well, personally I feel that – oh! Look over there! It’s a badger, with a gun! Yoink!
Read the rest of this entry »
Search
Read our finest words
Respond to our gibber
- Kadayi : “@ffordesoon Apology accepted. However I've presented counter arguments to your points, so you need to formulate a response to those.” on Obsidian Want To Know What You Want Them To Make
- propjoe : “Episode 1 Racer is my favorite racing game ever. I remember summers when a friend and I would spend what seemed like weeks alternating between ...” on The Sunday Papers
- Prime : “I sincerely hope you're joking. If not, perhaps you belong among the EG commenters, Unaco. It's quite eye-opening how many there seem to be lapping ...” on The Sunday Papers
- Lambchops : “@ AndrewC All I'm seeing is a lot of talk about how Skyrim can instantly transform from a solid state into the gas phase, which ...” on The Sunday Papers
- Kadayi : “@Prime I don't think they are quite in Duke Nukem territory yet, but they are dangerously close. One of the great problems with the medium ...” on The Sunday Papers
