I wasn’t really following the Mafia II is-it-good-or-nob controversy, for the simple reason that I thought it was probably a little bit nob. When the initial reviews came in, there was a clear division between people who thought it was a bit of a disappointment and people who thought it was supa-dupa-fly. To be honest, I presumed that the people who liked it were presumably just not very bright and had fell into the AAA-game + pretty + a bit of hype = 9/10 trap, because I can be just as judgemental as any reader when I put my mind to it. Quinns didn’t like it much. John felt similarly. Both particularly singled out the narrative for eye-rolling, with Walker noting it “should be damned is for its banal story” and despite the perhaps-best-ever acting “the lines they’re delivering, however, are blabber.”
So, no, none of this exactly put it on my To Play list.
Read the rest of this entry »