
It’s been a while since the first part of this, but the talking heads have talked their heads enough for a second part. Shawn Elliot’s lobbed it up yesterday, and I’m mirroring it here. I stress again – this is both classic TL;DR and total games journalist shop talk. If that’s not your thing, probably best click on something else. However, if you want to hear games journalists yabber about review ethics…
Read the rest of this entry »
Rock, Paper, Shotgun
Posts Tagged ‘Symposium’
Symposium Prt 2: Review Policy, Practice, Ethics
By Kieron Gillen on February 13th, 2009.
Symposium Part One: Review Scores
By Kieron Gillen on December 18th, 2008.

I’ve mentioned the Symposium I’m involved with before, in the Sunday Papers. It’s a multi-week exercise where a number of experienced writers from multiple fields are debating games journalism. It is about as meta and games-journalism-journalism as it can get. Shawn Elliot has posted the first part and I’m cross-posting it here, partially as an experiment. I stress, the following is about as shop talk as anything you’d have read about games journalism. It’s also very long. I’d only read it if you are deeply interested in the concept of games criticism and reviewing. And with that proviso, I hand over to Shawn…
Read the rest of this entry »
Search
Read our finest words
Respond to our gibber
- CaspianRoach : “Yeah, generalizing A Call for Communication for HL news with gamer entitlement is really far-fetched and is probably done for sensationalist press purposes. The guy ...” on The Sunday Papers
- Lakshmi : “My favourite part about this comment is the complete disregard for even the *idea* of women playing the game.” on By Your Command: FemShep Lives
- Prime : “Skyrim is sublime.” on The Sunday Papers
- MattM : “Telling (and selling) only half a story is a bit of a dick move. I don't think valve has any legal obligation to finish the ...” on The Sunday Papers
- Jerakal : “Wow, I can't disagree more with the guy who wrote the first article calling the people in Call for communication entitled. We've said more than ...” on The Sunday Papers

