Premature Evaluation: Universe Sandbox 2

Universe Sandbox 2 has some perfectly reasonable restrictions on what it is willing to simulate, but isn’t always clear about why it’s stopping you from doing something. I wanted to recreate the 0.1 fm wide black hole from Larry Niven’s 1973 story The Hole Man, for instance - and found the scale doesn’t descend that low. It’s not especially surprising that the game doesn’t model subatomic sizes, but getting the diameter below a couple of kilometres is also impossible and attempting to do so has this strange effect of deleting what you just typed and replacing it with the lowest number that the program will accept, and yet nonetheless changing a bunch of other stats that would be affected by a further reduction in diameter.

Each week Marsh Davies orbits the supermassive blackhole that is Early Access and comes back with any stories he can find or gets shredded to subatomic spaghetti as he tumbles towards a point of infinite mass. This week he has become death, destroyer of worlds, and really quite a lot of moons as well, in Universe Sandbox 2. Otherwise known as Universe Sandbox², if you’re the kind of terrible prick who insists on using Character Map to enforce your brand. Anyway, the game’s great.

Inexplicably, Earth begins to grow. Hour by hour, it just keeps putting on mass. The scientists can’t explain it. Where is all the weight coming from? It’s as if some malevolent god had discovered Earth’s settings panel and decided to yank up the mass slider, just to see what happens. What happens is that, as Earth reaches a mass equivalent to Jupiter – 318 times that of Earth’s normal mass – the orbits of other planets begin to distort alarmingly. Venus gets a bit too interested, spiralling after Earth then twisting away at the last moment, like an unsuccessful pickpocket. The planet swells further, its own rotation slowing and slowing. Somewhere, I like to think, semi-sentient hemorrhoid Donald Trump is honking about the myth of global enbiggenment just before being crushed to death by his own awful wig, which has become 35 times heavier than it was earlier that day.

Anyway, the reason for replicating this particular black hole is that Niven’s story was the template for a (w)hole lot of sci-fi stories in which a tiny black hole is lost within the centre of a planet and gradually consumes it from within. In Niven’s tale, the black hole is part of an ancient communication device discovered on Mars and held safely within some sort of electromagnetic confinement. However, a gigantic asshole decides to turn off that confinement in a successful attempt to assassinate a superior: it drops straight through him, boring a tunnel all the way down, and further into the centre of Mars, where it continues to oscillate around the core, gobbling up matter. Well, actually not gobbling: it’s a surprisingly dainty eater: the black hole itself is smaller than a proton, so it passes effortlessly through all material, even if the powerful tidal forces that surrounding it do damage at the much larger millimetre scale. But, being so small, it collides rarely with other particles to consume, and so grows relatively slowly to what you might expect from an untamed black hole, taking a full 40 years to consume Mars.

Moments later, Earth completes its transformation from happy blue-green habitation to gigantic blue-grey death vortex. When it hits a mass equivalent to 42 Jupiters, it begins to ignite, stripes of brilliant orange encircling the gloomy swirling globe. Venus is gravity-slapped clear out of the solar system. Earth’s surface temperature now exceeds 500 degrees centigrade. At 74.5 Jupiters, it becomes a molten glowing ball, and soon thereafter an actual sun, albeit a tenth of the mass of the system’s normal sun – which is nonetheless swerving through space as the two bodies waltz around one another. Mercury plunges directly into the heart of Hot Earth and is consumed utterly. Mars decides Venus had the right idea, and legs it. But it’s not nearly fast enough: the two suns can’t resist one another, conjoining violently to make a sweet fiery love that rapidly engulfs the core planets of the solar system, gobbling up the the Kuiper belt and spreading turquoise tendrils into the interstellar dark that lies beyond.

I did that. I can do loads of other things too, and the inhabitants of Earth will rarely thank me for them. What happens when you fire a teapot which is ten times larger than the sun through the heart of the solar system? Or if hapless scientists inadvertently create a black hole on Mars? What does the collision of two galaxies look like? Or the Earth being hit by a tennis ball the size of our own moon? Universe Sandbox 2 gives you the tools to run all such simulations in a level of depth which is at least superficially convincing and informative. It’s easy to use, beautifully tutorialised, and hugely fascinating. In fact, the sort of anarchic fun described above takes second place to the simple examination of how our solar system actually works. You can click on any body within it and bring up a panel which will allow you to modify everything from its semi-major axis to its argument of periapsis and a whole host of other things that don’t sound like erectile dysfunctions. But before I even tweaked a single albedo slider, I spent a good few hours just zipping about the solar system using the ample number of visualisation tools to examine the relative orbits and velocities of the bodies therein.

Though there are some arguments about exactly how a black hole unleashed into the centre of Mars would behave, if we assume that it continued to consume matter, then it would render the planet uninhabitable long before all of Mars had been devoured by it. One of the more colourful terms to enter the scientific lexicon is spaghettification: it describes what happens to objects as they are assaulted by the immense tidal forces created by the black hole’s warping of spacetime. If you were to make the mistake of getting too close to a black hole the size of Niven’s, the forces acting on the part of your body closest to it would be sufficiently different from your farthest point to stretch you into a string of atoms. While we don’t know what would await you at the black hole’s singularity, it’s safe to say you would not survive this process long enough to find out. It’s also safe to say that you would not, in those moments, discover that the fifth dimension is in fact love, and spend your remaining non-time haunting a bookshelf.

What particularly fascinated me were the dwarf planets and minor planets. Call me a pig-ignorant bumguff barely deserving of life, but I hadn’t really been aware of the number of these that exist in our own solar system. Open up the simulation entitled Solar System All Possible Dwarf Planets and you’ll see. Our solar system, which I tend to lazily think of as a sun, eight planets, the try-hard Pluto, and a handful of moons and rocks, has so many other bodies of significant mass that my PC begins to creak to a standstill. Luckily, the regular Solar System simulation picks a few of the more interesting ones to visualise. Take cold, lonely Sedna for isntance – a suspected dwarf planet that orbits the sun well beyond any other known body of similar mass. It’s hugely elliptical orbit means that it’s currently enjoying summery temperatures of -243 °C, wandering through the darkness some three times the distance Neptune is from the Sun. I can use the Universe Sandbox 2 to watch as it completes its fly-by, the data and my crude observation suggesting that it’ll come as close as it has been in 10428 years some time in 2065, before winding its way back out to a distance around 30 times further than Neptune.

If you want to get a sense of how far that is, you can use the “pulse” tool to track a burst of light from the sun, emitted in a ring, as it expands – at light-speed of course. It takes 4.1 hours to reach Neptune. 5.1 days to reach Sedna at its furthest point. Though I imagine it won’t take the edge off the chill – 10° above absolute zero. To get an idea of Sedna’s scale, you can switch to graph mode, which lines up each of the objects in the simulation side-by-side, reordering them based on whichever statistic you desire. Sedna’s a diddy 520 km in radius, a third of the size of our moon. You can map orbits and colour them to indicate velocity, acceleration or mass. There’s an entire page of simulations you can load designed only to produce pretty spirographic trails as bodies arc around one another. You can watch climate simulations, as the years etch away at the polar caps. You can examine the exact trajectory of NASA’s interplanetary paparazzi, the New Horizons, as it passes by Pluto. You can discover a binary star system which would explain the weather in Game of Thrones. Or you can spawn a simulation of Earth with 5000 moons and watch as your computer splutters.

You and Mars would be better off, at least initially, were you to fall into a much bigger black hole. Your fate would ultimately be the same, of course, but, for a black hole many millions of times the mass of the Sun, you would at least be able to pass beyond the event horizon without suffering the same spaghettification: the scale of the black hole would render the difference in forces on your aft and stern trivial. You would probably experience nothing especially remarkable about the event horizon at all, though you might note the light from other parts of the sky bending and distorting. To another observer, smart enough to keep some distance, you would appear to slow down as you approached the event horizon - not just in the sense that your movement towards it would appear to gradually halt, but that, if they could somehow see a watch on your wrist, it too would appear to be working slower and slower. You would also appear to become dimmer and dimmer until you became one with the total blackness of the hole itself.

There are loads of simulations of varying levels of absurdity and scale, and other pre-sets to toy with. The tutorials are clear, concise and elegantly demonstrate to you a few of the universe’s marvels: how to create a pulsar, for instance. But you can always create your own solar system from scratch, placing bodies and assigning trajectories as you like. And then, possibly, detonating it all afterwards. Call me a dumb ape-like genetic garbage golem, but my main problem with the game is currently that I know too little about the universe to know what would be interesting for me to then find out using Universe Sandbox 2: a few more tutorials of this kind, to give me a guided tour of basic astrophysics, would be welcome. Alt-tabbing to Wikipedia is no great hardship either, but I would nonetheless love some general writing about the things you are observing, to give you a sense of why they are remarkable – even though much of what is fascinating is evident from the simulation itself.

One thing that is not evident is how time advancement works: you can speed up and slow down the simulation, although, call me a grotesque idiot who should probably choke on his own tongue, but the tool for doing so is entirely incomprehensible to me. It seems to have some sort of sporadically effectual throttle and a text entry box that ignores whatever you put in it. This is a significant hindrance, as the solar system simulation maxed out at 3 years/per second, which meant it would have taken an hour before Sedna reached its furthest point from the Sun and I could note its effective surface temperature. Instead I edited the simulation, dragged Sedna from the warm bosom of the solar system and plonked it in the abyssal depths where the most distant point of its orbit was predicted to lie. I got the readout, but, having disrupted its orbit, Sedna now lost interest in our neighbourhood and wandered off into the night.

But from your perspective, things might be pretty ok. Sure, you are tumbling irrevocably into certain death - but when aren’t you? If the black hole was sufficiently massive, and you were peculiarly well-equipped, you might be able to live out your entire life before being spaghettified and plunging into the singularity. Not that we can really test out this theory any time soon: the nearest supermassive black hole is several thousands of light years away. There are some suggestions, however, that particle colliders like the Large Hadron Collider might be capable of producing micro black holes - though this is an extrapolation which requires the use of dimensions extra to the traditional four. This sounds alarming, but the likes of Stephen Hawkins say that micro black holes would evaporate near instantly and so pose no threat to the Earth. Indeed, it might even be possible to harness them as a power source. When has that ever gone wrong?

There are a few minor bugs (I once had Mercury headbutt the Sun out of existence) and not all the features are seemingly yet implemented (what does the habitable zone toggle do?), but the devs anticipate another whole year in Early Access, during which time more bespoke community-suggested simulations, like the New Horizons fly-by, will be added, as well as life simulation, terraforming, missions, space tethers and more. Call me a thicko dipshit who wallows in the slurry of his own stupidity, but even in its current form, Universe Sandbox 2 has done as much to lift me from my colossal ignorance as any game I’ve recently played. No mean feat.

Universe Sandbox 2 is available from Steam for £19, and directly from the developer, too. I played the version with the Build ID number 746711 on 27/08/2015.

From this site

20 Comments

  1. Premium User Badge

    Aerothorn says:

    It seems like this could just as easily be a review of Universe Sandbox – what has changed in the sequel (this is a genuine question, as the game’s marketing hasn’t helped me at all with this).

    • Runty McTall says:

      As an owner of the first one, either all almost everything Marsh mentioned is new or it was wildly obscured in the old one. This article seriously tempted me to pick up the new version but the price is a little steep for me (spent a few hours noodling around in the original but not serious time).

      VR compatibility would be a welcome addition for me.

      Also, top alt-text as ever Marsh :)

    • Luringen says:

      Off the top of my head, it’s remade in a new engine so it should run better, and climate simulation (melting polar caps, life, etc.) on planets is new as well.

  2. RedViv says:

    I like the Forest Moon of Endor / Death Star level in the first.

    Boom.

  3. Skabooga says:

    If the tinkering of this game could be combined with the exploration focus of Space Engine (link to en.spaceengine.org), I might never need to buy another game again.

  4. Premium User Badge

    Andy_Panthro says:

    “Sure, you are tumbling irrevocably into certain death – but when aren’t you?”

    Great article as always!

    My favourite solar system fact is that the sum of all the diameters of all of the planets (including pluto!) is slightly less than the distance between the earth and the moon (at its farthest point in its orbit).

    • Premium User Badge

      Arnvidr says:

      Makes for interesting images.

    • JRHaggs says:

      ^ I really don’t understand this…

      Would you mind explaining?

      • JRHaggs says:

        I mean, does an ellipse even have a diameter?

        For some reason, thinking about this has made me rather irritable.

        • JRHaggs says:

          Ugh. The planets. Not their orbits. Goddammit.

          Ignore all that crap above.

  5. Cockie says:

    The max time speed is understandable – to speed up a N-body simulation without letting your CPU vaporize you have to let it take bigger steps between each ‘frame’. However, bigger steps means less accuracy and at a certain point you start getting glaring errors – moons flying out of orbit for no apparent reason and whatnot.

  6. ButteringSundays says:

    Sure, this is where it starts, next thing you have little hominids in your simulation pondering creation.

    • quietone says:

      When you want to quit the simulation just send a Jesus down there and voilà! Everything’s saved!

    • ironhorse says:

      Who then create another universe simulation within their microverse to power your car battery?

  7. Mr Propellerhead says:

    Fjord editor?

  8. AnTREXon says:

    I love the game.

    Here’s how I used science in the game to explain the crazy seasons of The Game of Thrones:

  9. Cinek says:

    I bought it on one of these days when it was on a sale and I felt like buying some random game for next to no reason.

    Well… that was a disappointment. I played like… 2 hours and I felt like I’ve seen everything that’s there to see. Even made my own solar system… but… there’s nothing to do with it. In general I like sandbox games, but this thing here feels… exceptionally pointless.

    So I have no idea how people spend dozens of hours running this stuff. Do they use it as a screensaver? Cause I can’t think of anything you could possibly do with this “game”. Is it even a game? It’s more like an application… an engine demo, more than anything else.

  10. xyzzy frobozz says:

    Call me a Rock Paper Shotgun reader who is easily annoyed, but I found the repeated appeals to call the author various long winded insults to be quite annoying.