The Flare Path: Gongs and Gripes

flarepath01

Although Combat Mission: Beyond Overlord doesn’t do medals, The Flare Path does. If you’ve been following the fortunes of Caent’s doughty defenders for the past three weeks, you may be interested to learn that a) the scenario used is now available for download, and b) several units involved in the action were decorated for their efforts.

(This week’s FP also includes some impressions of 303 Squadron: Battle of Britain, an Early Access air combat game that’s more Defiant than Spitfire at the moment.)

flarepath02

An Iron Cross mit Oak Leaves, Swords, Pixies and Honey Badgers, went to Teichert’s FJ squad who, despite arriving on the battlefield fairly late in the day, managed to KO a Universal Carrier and notch up our side’s most impressive anti-infantry tally (19 Tommies topped or stopped).

flarepath03

Larcher’s team, the pioneer HQ that stubbornly defended the cottage next to the hotel until wiped out in Turn 16, received the same medal minus the Honey Badgers for reducing enemy ranks by 18 – a staggering achievement considering that, at their strongest, they only fielded two MP 40s, a Kar98K and a Luger.

flarepath15

Two infantry units earned Tank Destruction Badges for their AT feats. A posthumous silver one went to Stein, the plucky pioneer who finally put the Churchill VII out of its misery in Turn 11, and Sheaffer, our perpetually panting Panzerschreck operator, received a bronze example for swatting the Wasp in Turn 17.

flarepath05

Happily, the top brass weren’t wholly guided by kill statistics when deciding who got gongs. Without the sterling work of Imhof, the mortar spotter (4 infanty casualties caused and 1 mortar destroyed) and Gruber, the pyromaniac (3 infantry casualties caused) the British assaults in the west and centre may well have proved unstoppable. Both men received posthumous clockwork Donner und Blitzen clasps in recognition of disruptive mayhem caused.

flarepath08

Brenner? Two hours after our mercurial Hetzer commander received a platinum Deutsches Kreuz and a case of calvados for slaying the rampaging Stuart and one of the Cromwells, the calvados bottles were empty and the medal was adorning the burr-studded fleece of an impressive ram near Carpiquet.

flarepath06

Axis stats in full:

Halftrack (none)
Hetzer (1 inf, 1 Stuart, 1 Cromwell)
PSW armoured car (none)

Nerbul – rifle platoon leader (5 inf)
Rifle squad 1 – the bakery defenders (11 inf)
Rifle squad 2 – the AVRE victims (none)
Rifle squad 3 – the broken squad (6 inf)

Larcher – Pioneer platoon leader (18 inf)
Stein’s squad (3 inf, 1 Churchill)
Mogg’s squad (1 inf)

Schenck – FJ platoon leader (2 inf)
Teichert’s squad (19 inf, 1 Universal Carrier)
Bulau’s squad (12 inf)
Schulmeister’s squad (2 inf)

Flamethrower team (3 inf)
LMG team (none)
Mortar spotter (4 inf, 1 mortar)
Pak 38 (2+2 inf, 1 Cromwell)
Panzerschreck (1 inf, 1 Wasp)
Sniper (none)

flarepath07

High-achieving Allied units:

Stuart (2 inf, 1 pillbox, 1 PSW armoured car, 1 halftrack)
Sgt. Fisher’s rifle squad – last seen heading north, close to Gruber’s body (7 inf)
Sgt. Hinchcliffe’s rifle squad – stormed Larcher’s cottage (6 inf)
Sgt. Carrington’s rifle squad – perished behind hotel (5 inf)

Oddly, neither the Wasp or Churchill AVRE were credited with any kills.

flarepath10

*       *       *

303a

If 303 Squadron: Battle of Britain was a Battle of Britain aircraft, it would be a Boulton Paul Defiant. Like the RAF’s first/last ‘turret-fighter’, Atomic Jelly’s first attempt at flight simulation catches the eye by fusing incongruous elements, is powered by a capable engine, and is horribly easy to shoot down.

303b

The concept – a light BoB sim with a living, breathing aerodrome at its heart, and dismantlable Hawker Hurricanes in its hangars – looked wizard on the drawing board. What I hadn’t bargained for was the charmless dogfighting, the exasperatingly rigid campaign structure, and the almost total disconnect between the game’s ground and air components.

303d

Elaborately modelling the fabric of an entire 1940 RAF fighter station and then not allowing your players to view that fighter station from the air or feel its runways beneath their Dunlops takes a special kind of sadism. Because all missions seem to start and end in the air miles from anything resembling West London, we’re denied the thrill of the scramble and the satisfaction of hairy homecomings.

303g

Worse, the sorties are as prefabricated as Nissen huts and often involve non-negotiable binary victory conditions. Atomic Jelly use Northolt primarily as a sprawling history dissemination device (between sorties much time is spent cycling between scattered Polish squadron-mates eager to share historical tidbits clearly plucked from period memoirs). This would be fine if they didn’t then go and compromise their scholarship by forcing you to perform preposterous feats aloft to progress. Destroy all four fighters… Shoot down all eight bombers before they drop their bombs… trite, brittle objectives like these manage to be both maddening and misleading.

303h

There’s no free flight or configurable skirmish mode at present, but in the light of the Hurricane’s bland, spin-free handling, inexhaustible ammunition boxes, and welded shut canopy (bailing out is impossible) that’s not something you’re likely to lose sleep over.

303e

My brushes with Emils and Flying Pencils thus far (I’m struggling to defeat the fifth sortie) have been pretty forgettable affairs. The Deer Hunter-style slo-mo bullet cam that activates every time you pump Pb in the direction of a Daimler-Benz DB 601 or a Bramo 323, is a nice touch, but I fear my abiding memories of 303’s early furballs will be the poor sound effects and awful radio chatter. Utterances like “You ground him!” and “Holy… Judging by the way they’re swarming, one might think both Jerry planes come with a pilot included when rolled out at the factory” fire-axe any ambience generated by the passable virtual cockpits.

303f

Involved aircraft repair and maintenance might have redeemed Early Access 303. What’s offered instead, judging by the hangar sessions near the start of the campaign, is a component upgrade mechanic far too shallow to divert the way Car Mechanic Simulator or Gun Disassembly 2 diverts.

303i

After mentioning last week that this impressions piece was in the offing, Cederic, a reader, reminded me that he’d pitched a similar game concept to the Flare Path design dragons, months before 303 was announced. The idea didn’t make the shortlist, but rereading it, I find myself wishing 303 was more like the tightly focussed, dogfight-dodging REMF

remf02

REMF

by Cederic

September 1939, you complete your basic training and become a Royal Air Force SAC. Posted to an airfield in [Kent|Lincolnshire|Somerset] you join a [Fighter|Bomber|Nightfighter] squadron.

As the aircraft land you read the pilot notes on any issues, perform your own visual inspection then execute the requisite repairs. Initially it’s a sticking flap, a misfiring cylinder. As the war progresses the damage includes bullet holes, oil leaks and regrettably heavy landings. Some pilots provide better info than others, and you get to know their accuracy and preferences (repair priorities).

remf06

The Battle of Britain forces short-cuts; which aspects of the aeroplane must you repair before the next sortie, which wrecks are good only for spares (and can you harvest them in re-usable condition) and which aircraft can be patched up while the crews are in the spare over the Channel. Strong time pressures force prioritisation between specific repairs, rearming and refuelling an aircraft.

Regular news reports and RAF briefings keep you abreast of the war’s progress. Your contribution directly affects the availability of aircraft and the survival of your squadron’s aircrews, and their success influences the war effort itself and the availability of spares and luxuries.

remf03

As you progress your career you gain the ability to work on more complex parts of the aircraft, more complex aircraft or promotion to Chief Technician, having responsibility across the whole squadron – inspecting/prioritising repairs across all of the aircraft, getting covered in oil to fix only one or two yourself.

The gameplay could include aspects comparable to existing ‘point and click’ engineer/mechanic simulators but with a challenging visual inspection regime. A strong logistical management element would require assessment of parts removed from aircraft (should they be re-used, fixed and re-used, sent away for repair or scrapped), careful use of new parts, shenanigans to source new parts (RAF Squadrons resorted to some very naughty tactics to assure their own aircraft remained airworthy) and the gamble on whether to let a pilot take out a less than optimal aircraft, risking him, the aircraft and the precious spares you just fitted to it.

remf04

The game would avoid any combat roles but should model enemy action against the airfield. This could be interactive, fleeing the hangar to find a slit trench or more robust shelter, or (simpler to implement) reported through loss of aircraft, parts and staff.

Exclude: ground assaults against the base. Consider: civil life (romance, rations, etc).

Suggested starting line-up: Hurricane, Spitfire, Beaufighter, Wellington. Later add Mosquito, Spitfire variants (inc. recon), Lancaster, etc, although ideally they’d be unlockable as you progress the main game – use DLC for other countries.

Commercially the game is (sadly) ripe for DLC, with new aircraft types/models, new airfields and entirely new countries – any of the major powers involved in the war.

Win conditions: Warrant Officer (or commission?) before the end of the war, with promotions coming from repairs, squadron performance, availability of parts and working aircraft.

*       *       *

 

This way to the foxer

18 Comments

  1. Harmodios says:

    Die Generalität, wie Her Stone, ist das Geschmeiß des deutschen Volkes! Sie ist ohne Ehre! Sie nennen sich Generale, weil Sie Jahre auf Militärakademien zugebracht haben. Nur um zu lernen, wie man Messer und Gabel hält! Jahrelang hat das Militär meine Aktionen nur behindert! Es hat mir jeden nur erdenklichen Widerstand in den Weg gelegt! Ich hätte gut daran getan, vor Jahren alle höheren Offiziere liquidieren zu lassen, wie Stalin!

    Ich war nie auf einer Akademie. Und doch habe ich allein, allein auf mich gestellt, ganz Caen erobert! Verräter. Von allem Anfang an bin ich nur verraten und betrogen worden! Es wurde ein ungeheurer Verrat geübt am deutschen Volke. Aber alle diese Verräter werden bezahlen. Mit ihrem eigenen Blutwerden sie zahlen. Sie werden ersaufen in ihrem eigenen Blut.

    Meine Befehle sind in den Wind gesprochen. Es ist unmöglich, unter diesen Umständen zu führen. Es ist aus. Europa ist verloren.

  2. Stugle says:

    I’ll avail myself of that file tonight and I’ll see how spectacularly I can fail. :)

    Thanks again for the CC, it’s been fun.

    I’m sorry to hear that 303 Squadron didn’t pan out as expected. When you covered it earlier, it showed a lot of promise for a nice different slant on the BoB.

  3. Crimson_Pig says:

    Good old Brenner, I hope he survives the war. Also I wish that Wodtke would have been more useful. He certainly had many chances for that.

    • khamul says:

      Wodtke did great work spotting for us, I believe, even if he didn’t achieve much on his own.

      Bit late to add my voice to the chorus, due to being in parts of the world with less internet and time, but that was super, Tim, thank you! Looking forward to next year’s already.

      And glad that my own somewhat questionable contributions in the early game didn’t get in the way of a successful conclusion in the end.

      • ItAintNecessarilySo says:

        I would actually say all units had their use. The LMG may not have any kills credited to their name, but they sure did a hell of a job holding the right flank so long that no Para’s could pose any real threat to the center.

      • heretic says:

        Yup! Can’t wait for the next installment of comment commanders :)

  4. DirtyDevo says:

    Tim Stone, you are a gentleman and a scholar.
    Perhaps your next project could be a 2019 West End revival: link to en.wikipedia.org

  5. Michael Fogg says:

    Say the scenario had no turn limit. Allies breaking through eventually or being pushed to the sea?

    • sagredo1632 says:

      Obviously Brenner would have exited the TD and it would be all over for the Allies.

    • beleester says:

      Stalemate, it really depends on who’s in command. The Allies have slightly more men (61 to 51), and a functional AVRE that could flatten our fortifications. Not to mention their mortar team and the paras flanking us on the right. The Germans have defensive positions, but the Hetzer is effectively knocked out so our only AT weapons are the Panzerschreck and our FJ’s Panzerfausts.

      But clever commanding could turn the tide in the Axis’ favor – sneak a Panzerfaust close to that Churchill, and they’re facing an even fight against a dug-in enemy, which is not a good spot to be in.

  6. AtlasIsKing says:

    Hi Tim! I just wanted to reinforce that I, as with many others greatly enjoyed the comment commanding series as I do every year. I still didn’t get involved in the commenting but I was gripped by the action anyways. Keep on doin’ what you’re doin’, Flare Path and associated reporting might just be the best regular event on the internet.

  7. Premium User Badge

    The Almighty Moo says:

    Thanks again Comment Commanders and Tim for an exciting reason to check RPS every morning for an update. While not as nail biting as last year’s excursio. A long time advocate of RPS generally, CCM annually sees me extolling the virtues of the site to gamers and others alike in attempt to get them engaged, with surprising success. Thanks Tim, I know that the executing and writing up of these sessions is no mean feat and I hope you do not underestimate the expressions of enjoyment from long time lurkers like myself.

  8. CookPassBabtridge says:

    Not covering FSLabs’s ongoing case of pointing an M249 with infinite ammunition at their feet and squeezing for all they’re worth? Shortlist of hatstand wibble level actions: Threatening reddit with legal action for letting their commenters say bad things about FSLabs putting malware in their products; Breaking Microsoft recommended practice by putting dodgy files in system32 folder; Demanding that news sites break privacy laws to give them personal details of people posting negative comments on their sites and cease negative coverage of their very negative actions; Using a beta tester to act as their “PR Manager” to write messages on reddit that sound like a condescending handkerchief-carrying Marquis from the 17th Century … weirdest shiz this century in flightsim right now. The Digital Homicide of FS.

Comment on this story

HTML: Allowed code: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>