The best PC games ever Best PC games of 2018 Best graphics card 2019 Best free games Dota Underlords builds Teamfight Tactics guide

14

MSI X570 Gaming Edge review: Great performance without breaking the bank

A great foundation for new AMD PCs

Featured post

If you’re thinking about buying one of AMD’s Ryzen 3000 CPUs, such as the excellent Ryzen 7 3700X, then you may want to think about pairing it with one of their new X570 motherboards. AMD’s Ryzen 3000 CPUs still work with older AM4 motherboards, of course, including those with X470 or B450 chipsets, but they may need a BIOS update before you can start using it (check our motherboard / CPU combo guide for more info), which isn’t the case for the out-of-the-box ready X570 boards. X570 boards also support the new super-fast PCIe 4.0 standard, which can chuck twice as much data around than their PCIe 3.0 predecessors – up to 64GB/s compared to 32GB/s.

That doesn’t mean much right now, admittedly, as there are still precious few PCIe 4.0 devices around to take advantage of all that extra speed. However, if you’re the type who likes to look ahead when building their PC, MSI’s MPG X570 Gaming Edge (Wi-Fi) motherboard is a great place to start.

Priced at £220 / $210, it’s quite a bit more expensive than a lot of older X470 boards you can buy right now, but compared to other X570 mobos (many of which top £300 / $300, if not £400 / $400), it’s probably one of the fastest and better value boards I’ve tested so far.

The MSI Gaming Edge doesn’t come with as many USB ports as other X570 boards, but you still get a pretty decent selection of USB 3.2 ports, plus a USB-C port.

Starting with general PC performance, the MSI X570 Gaming Edge was able to hold its own pretty well against its considerably more expensive rivals. Indeed, with a Geekbench 4.3 single core of 5232, the MSI X570 Gaming Edge is around 3-4% faster than the £390 / $380 Asus ROG Crosshair VIII Hero (Wi-Fi), £297 / $300 AsRock X570 Taichi and £390 / $360 Gigabyte X570 Aorus Master, while its multicore performance was pretty much identical. Here, the MSI finished with a score of 32,296, which was only a couple of hundred points behind the Asus and AsRock (not even 1%), and about a thousand (3%) in front of the Gigabyte.

It also put in the best performance in PCMark 10’s general productivity benchmark, too, finishing with a score of 6640 overall. That’s a 17% increase over MSI’s older X470 Gaming M7 AC that I reviewed when AMD’s 2nd Gen Ryzen CPUs came out.

The MSI X570 Gaming Edge can support up to 128GB of DDR4 RAM with speeds ranging between 1866-2666MHz by default, but if you enable its OC mode it can run RAM up to 4400MHz.

As for the X570 Gaming Edge’s gaming performance, this once again produced the nippiest speeds in my suite of test games. Admittedly, we’re only talking a difference of 1-3fps here in a lot of cases, but it shows you don’t need to spend almost £400 / $400 on an X570 motherboard to get the best speeds from your new CPU.

In Shadow of the Tomb Raider, for example, the MSI X570 Gaming Edge produced an average frame rate of 111fps in its internal benchmark on Highest at 1080p with its TAA anti-aliasing enabled, which just squeaks in front of the Gigabyte’s 110fps, the Asus’ 109fps and the AsRock’s 108fps. The MSI also had the edge at 1440p as well, as it was the only one able to stay in triple figures (100fps) when I ran the benchmark again with the same quality settings. The rest finished with averages between 98-99fps.

Both of the MSI X570 Gaming Edge’s PCIe x16 slots support the new, super-fast PCIe 4.0 standard, but only the top one runs at the full x16 speed. The second one runs at x4.

It also came joint first with the Asus Crosshair in Total War: Warhammer II as well. At 1080p on Ultra, both motherboards produced an average of 107fps, while the Gigabyte was only able to muster an average of 105fps, and the AsRock 106fps. The AsRock clawed it back at 1440p, mind, coming in with an average of 94fps to match the MSI and Asus, but the Gigabyte was only able to manage 92fps.

In fact, it was only Assassin’s Creed Odyssey where the MSI fell behind, finishing its internal benchmark with an average of 74fps as opposed to the 75-77fps scores achieved by the other three boards. However, considering it’s so much cheaper than the other lot, there’s hardly much to complain about in the grand scheme of things – especially when it hit an identical 66fps average to the Gigabyte when I raised the resolution to 1440p, which was only a single frame behind the Asus and AsRock.

The MSI X570 Gaming Edge has two M.2 slots for NVMe SSDs, but only the top one (underneath the heatsink) supports the super-fast PCIe 4.0 standard.

As for SSD performance, I tested the MSI X570 Gaming Edge with both my standard PCIe 3.0 WD Black NVMe SSD as well as Gigabyte’s Aorus NVMe Gen4 SSD to see how it handled a PCIe 4.0 device. Starting with the WD, this was pretty much in line with the other three X570 boards I’ve tested, producing a random read speed of 45.6MB/s and a random write speed of 150.4MB/s. The latter is perhaps a bit slow compared to the competition, the fastest of which was able to reach 178.7MB/s, but once again I’m not too bothered by this considering its lower price.

Its PCIe 4.0 performance, however, was faster than Gigabyte’s Aorus Master board, and neck and neck with Asus’ Crosshair, coming in with 66.7MB/s random read and 162.1MB/s random write. As for the AsRock, I wasn’t actually able to fit the Gigabyte SSD onto that particular board, as its built-in heatsink panel didn’t leave enough room for it. Likewise, even if I’d removed the AsRock’s heatsink panel, I would have had to have left it dangling around inside my case due to the small cluster of wires attaching it to the main board, which is neither very practical or something you’d want to put up with long-term.

You’ll have to remove the heatsink to access the MSI X570 Gaming Edge’s PCIe 4.0-enabled M.2 slot, but at least the whole thing can be removed, unlike other X570 boards where it’s attached by a handful of wires.

All in all, then, the MSI X570 Gaming Edge looks like pretty good value at the moment, at least compared to the more expensive X570 boards I’ve tested so far. There are, admittedly, a couple of quality of life niggles I have with this board – it doesn’t come with a nice, smooth backplate, for example, nor does it come with a front panel connector doodad like its more expensive competition. You also only get two SATA cables, two M.2 screws (no stand-offs) and its Wi-Fi antenna included in the box, whereas other boards will get you a lot more.

However, when the MSI’s performance is either quicker or just as fast as those more upmarket boards, I’m more than happy to do without these little extras for the sake of saving myself a bit of cash. After all, why spend another £100 / $100 on an equally fast motherboard when you could be putting that toward a better graphics card, or another, larger SSD?

I’ll do my best to get more X570 motherboards in for testing as soon as I can, but for now, the MSI MPG X570 Gaming Edge (Wi-Fi) is a great foundation for anyone looking to get the most out of their new AMD Ryzen 3000 CPU without breaking the bank.

Tagged with , , , , , , .

If you click our links to online stores and make a purchase we may receive a few pennies. Find more information here.

Who am I?

Katharine Castle

Hardware Editor

Katharine writes about all the bits that go inside your PC so you can carry on playing all those lovely games we like talking about so much. Very partial to JRPGs and the fetching of quests.

More by me

Support RPS and get an ad-free site, extra articles, and free stuff! Tell me more
Please enable Javascript to view comments.

Please log in to reply.

Advertisement

Latest videos