Results 1,081 to 1,100 of 4183
Thread: Women vs Tropes in Video Games
28-05-2013, 09:11 PM #1081
28-05-2013, 09:38 PM #1082
We warned: has some mild story spoilers for some games. But nothing that major /imhoPlanetside 2: bobby is going home
28-05-2013, 09:54 PM #1083
28-05-2013, 10:01 PM #1084
28-05-2013, 10:07 PM #1085
I'll watch it shortly and edit this to add comments, but I strongly appreciate the spoiler list provided. It was one of my (petty?) irks about the first that some good stuff was spoiled for people, even if the arguments were well made. Whilst some will inevitably be included, simply providing the warning is good enough for me.
2.51 - ...blimey, that was a long list.
4.45 - That Pandora's Tower looks awful. In so many ways. That's the only clip I've seen of it too.
7.20 - Haha. Guess I need to see Wreck-It-Ralph!
8.04 - *Sniggers* I love how monotone the line has become. "Your wife is brutally murdered and you have to rescue your daughter."
12.10 - I love that she's barely containing her laughter with the plot reveal of Bionic Commando and... 12.26 - Nope, there we go. Haha.
18.55 - Boom, and that's the key thing. Repeated use is the problem, not just one here or there.
20.38 - Agreed.
Ok, done...okay, just re-watched the Bionic Commando part.
Yeah, so full agreement with this one. Nothing at all I could think of.
28-05-2013, 10:40 PM #1086
28-05-2013, 10:47 PM #1087
28-05-2013, 10:54 PM #1088
- Join Date
- Oct 2011
And will have to go through the week long process of DMCA take downs?
Although it said youtube TOS, where I think copyrights normally list who claimed it.
28-05-2013, 10:59 PM #1089
Well, the first one is still there, so it probably isn't simply because of copyright.
28-05-2013, 11:25 PM #1090
28-05-2013, 11:41 PM #1091
28-05-2013, 11:45 PM #1092
I enjoyed it. I'm hoping that after the next video about listing dudes in distress etc. we get a video to round off that topic and maybe get in a little deeper after establishing the various narrative techniques and cliches.
28-05-2013, 11:48 PM #1093
28-05-2013, 11:51 PM #1094
- Join Date
- Feb 2012
- Stockton-on-Tees, UK
Interestingly I've only played one game that is mentioned in that video, as far as I can tell.Irrelevant on further examination of the rest of the thread.
29-05-2013, 12:30 AM #1095
I think she should back up a few of the points she makes more, like saying killing your possessed girlfriend in a game because she asks you to is equivalent to condoning violence against women in the real world or saying "Women are asking for it!" is a bit of a leap. I also think she over-uses the trope buzzwords. It really is like listening to someone read TV Tropes.
I found the last 5 minutes by the strongest analysis she does in the video. That part pretty much made it worth watching. Although I wish she had trimmed down the first 20 minutes a lot.
29-05-2013, 12:49 AM #1096
29-05-2013, 01:09 AM #1097
Hopefully she will get to it in future videos.
Last edited by iridescence; 29-05-2013 at 01:12 AM.
29-05-2013, 01:14 AM #1098
Oh no here we go.
My thoughts (which no doubt people will bitch at me for again):
1 - A lot of her list does demonstrate that the trope still exists, but I think some of those lack context. Max Payne 3 for example - it makes sense and doesn't come off as overly contrived. I can totally get that a bunch of... well, everyone apparently, kidnap a female party girl for an extortion attempt. EDIT: Well on reflection she does acknowledge context later, but then tries to divorce it from the story so...?
2 - At least she acknowledged that some of these characters fight back, but then she goes "Inevitably they prove futile." Yes, it's a plot device. It's overplayed, you've well and truly proven that point, but she still hasn't really established how this is a significant problem outside of being a lazy trope.
3 - Her point about reinforcing that women are desirable because of their powerlessness... I'm in two minds. On the one hand, yeah I guess I can sort of agree. But in some ways it's a long bow to draw. In some games the love interest is established between the characters prior to the damsel event, or the event strengthens the bond. That doesn't necessarily mean that the feelings of affection were strengthened purely because of the disempowerment, instead of a desire to help someone in need. That seems like a bit of a leap in logic, but the way a lot of them are framed still fits Anita's description, so I guess I'm on the fence.
4 - "Woman in the refrigerator": Again, it's a trope. I get it. But again, how is this really contributing to gender imbalance besides just being an overused plot device? Yes, the reverse doesn't appear in games. That may be because most games are marketed towards men. That doesn't make it right, but that's the truth. There's no real demonstration how this plot device is a problem besides being overused. I mean I could make the same point out of "Suddenly... DEMONS" or something like that. She does make one excellent point - the attempt at including violence purely to justify a "mature" tag is bullshit. Then she says that they cross the line into misogyny. Really? How?
5 - Haha, Bionic Commando.
6 - Euthanised Damsel: Uh, yeah, it's a poor attempt at provoking an emotional response. Yes, overused. Again, not certain how she can demonstrate that it's harmful or really misogynist. Something being a trope does not make it misogynist. Saying that she's "asking for it" is ripping it entirely out of context. Then the Domestic violence stuff: What?! What?! Yes, games don't exist in a vacuum. But that doesn't suddenly mean the context of the game is entirely irrelevant. Then she lists a load of statistics about violence against women as if this is somehow a linked concept. I actually didn't have much criticism for the video right up until this part, when logic went straight out the window.
7 - The last 5 minutes are pretty much the best words I've ever heard her say. I have no criticisms at all. I agree. Only point I would make is that I don't necessarily believe that any of this justifies why these tropes are necessarily bad. I agree that it's an overused plot device which does have some cultural impact, but I don't know if that really makes a strong enough case that the tropes are bad. Overused? Yes. Limiting? Yes. Shortsighted? Yes. Enough to claim misogyny? Don't know. She does nail it with Max Payne and failed hero stuff. Oh, and Dear Esther was not that creative. And it's not a game.
Conclusion: Much better than her first, which was basically a list of tropes, but I still have a few issues. Firstly, it's still primarily a list of tropes which we already know are overplayed. They've overplayed in games, movies, pretty much anything that has a story. I don't think anyone disputes that. This time Anita tried to do a bit of analysis, and in some cases I agree. But there are some major leaps of logic here, particularly the one about the "euthanised damsel" reinforcing or justifying domestic violence. If we accept that games don't encourage violence behaviour, then by extension I have to accept that games don't encourage domestic violence. Her attempts to divorce context from the story just because games have a cultural impact is also ridiculous and a weak attempt to strengthen her argument. I don't have too many issues with this video (save the domestic violence stuff) except that it doesn't really make a case except that the trope is overused. She still hasn't actually demonstrated the harm. Where she has attempted to do so (which is better than last time) there are a few tenuous connections and one ridiculous leap in logic. Disappointing, but not as bad as last time.Nalano's Law - As an online gaming discussion regarding restrictions grows longer, the probability of a post likening the topic to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea approaches one.
Soldant's Law - A person will happily suspend their moral values if they can express moral outrage by doing so.
29-05-2013, 01:16 AM #1099
Faux Action Girl. All attitude and spunk and inferred ability... until she needs to be saved. First part says "you're awesome," but the second part is why the protagonist cares.
29-05-2013, 06:54 AM #1100
- Join Date
- Jun 2011
But Samus Aran! Lara Croft!