Wot I Think: All Walls Must Fall

allwallsmustfall5

Bullets tear across a sweating dancefloor, heaving with bodies. Flashes of metal and flesh, lights pulsing and skittering across glistening bodies. All Walls Must Fall’s nightclub shoot-outs are a devilish dream, capturing at once the brilliance of Terminator’s Tech Noir horror and the actual punk in cyberpunk. I just wish there was more to the game than a thousand murders on the dancefloor.

If you ask me – and by clicking here, you did – we’re living in rough times when it comes to cyberpunk. The genre has always been prone to putting its style above any substance, or even above any semblance of substance, but it’s a style I like so I never thought the day would come when I found myself bored of all that moody neon and rain-slick streets.

That day is here though. I’m so tired of futures packed with sad/sexy/cool/but-definitely-sad strip clubs and sexbots, visited and used by men so stoical they might as well not exist. All the beautiful cityscapes and sunglasses-at-night in the world aren’t enough to keep my interest when all that seems to remain is glib pandering to an aesthetic amputated from anger, sorrow or meaning.

Altered Carbon and Mute are recent examples, both appearing on Netflix with varying degrees of fanfare. One, a fairly high budget adaptation of a novel, given a full series treatment so that its world-building and characters can really breathe within their sleeves. The other is the much-anticipated sci-fi successor to Duncan Jones’ beloved debut, Moon. It’s the latter that has received the most vigorous critical kicking, though the backlash against the backlash has no doubt begun, but I couldn’t find the willpower to finish either of them. And that’s because they both felt like visual fan-fiction, devoted to a cyberpunk ur-text that I’m not even sure exists.

What is a genre? A miserable little pile of tropes.

allwallsmustfall6

Thankfully, there are bright spots. All Walls Must Fall is one. Made by a team of ex-YAGER developers, is a game about aggression, seduction, persuasion and lies. The story concerns an endless cold war, fuelled by time manipulation that allows agents on both sides to counter one another and rewrite history as it happens. It’s a big idea but, sensibly, the game focuses on a few specific moments in a few particular places rather than throwing you at the big picture.

The focus is on the nightlife of Berlin and it’s violent, flirtatious, gorgeously soundtracked and dripping with sex and death. Keeping its ideas big and its canvas small is both All Walls Must Fall’s smartest decision and its greatest weakness. But before I go into that, here’s how it all works.

allwallsmustfall2

Each mission tasks you with infiltrating a club and completing a task within that club. The first goal is to enter and that might involve hacking a security camera, to make sure no drones are dispatched to your location, or convincing the bouncer to let you inside. Conversations involve picking from a series of responses to try and raise one positive emotional state to its maximum before a negative trait maxes out instead, ruining everything.

Threatening, flirting, lying and confusing are all possible. I particularly enjoyed pretending to be a superior, dispatched from some imaginary headquarters to deal with anything from a broken ventilation system to a potentially fatal catastrophe. Sometimes a guard will stand up to your lies and you can change tack, making light of the whole situation, but even if you’re the sharpest talker in Berlin, you’re going to have to resort to violence at some point.

And violence, in the form of turn-based shoot-outs, is more important and more enjoyable than all of the exploring and talking. That’s true to the extent that everything else quickly felt like the punctuation around the shoot-outs, which is a little disappointing given how much I want a game about flirting my way through the gay nightclubs of Berlin. This is not that game.

allwallsmustfall3

Given how much time you’ll spend shooting, it’s a good thing that the combat is the most stylish part of a very stylish game. It’s where most of the substance lives as well, though that’s not clear during the first few exchanges of bullets, which are likely to involve little more than moving behind cover and then shooting to stun, then to kill.

Even in a simple exchange the delights of All Walls Must Fall’s musical murdering are obvious. First, you queue up instructions, seeing the results play out in jerky fashion, enemies moving, then player character moving. It’s all standard stuff. But when the last enemy is down, provided no reinforcements are incoming (and later on, there will be many reinforcements incoming), you confirm all of your actions. The game says you “drop it”, because it’s that kind of game and it’s going to convert all of that tactical clicking into a gorgeous real-time cartoon with beats to (literally) die for.

It’s what would happen if Baby Driver was on the back-end of a five-day drug binge and decided to pull a heist in the future.

allwallsmustfall4

And there’s a reason for it, beyond the aesthetic. As you move through the randomised missions that make up a run-through of the game, you’ll buy new weapons and temporal manipulation skills. The latter allow you to do all kinds of tricksy things like intentionally triggering some drones, then rewinding their actions but not your own so that you can sort of stealth your way between moments. In later missions – a full campaign is 12 missions, grouped in loosely connected trios – you’ll need all the tactical time-twisting you can muster to survive.

Being shot will kill you after a couple of hits but because you’re a visitor to this time period, able to skip around from moment to moment and scratch time like a DJ spinning a record, death isn’t final unless you’ve quite literally run out of time. You can always step back from the brink and watch the bullets leave your body as the blood returns.

Time is your key resource and you receive more as you explore, which gives a reason to scope out rooms rather than heading directly to marked objectives. There are also tons of collectibles in the form of groovy posters and delicious cocktails, with all ingredients listed.

And that’s pretty much it. Shooting, talking, exploring clubs, collecting things, and moving through a plot that’s decent but slightly threadbare.

allwallsmustfall1

Given how odd the whole game is, some comparisons might be useful. It mostly reminds me of Invisible, Inc., mostly due to the brevity of the campaigns and replayability. All Walls Must Fall lacks the variety and precision of Klei’s masterpiece though and where Invisible, Inc. feels like a much grander game than the component parts might suggest, All Walls Must Fall is narrow. Dense, at times, but narrow.

As I wrote earlier, that’s both the source of its greatest strengths and weaknesses. It’s an easy game to bleed dry – even though you won’t have seen everything on a single playthrough, the second or third are likely to make you feel like you really are caught in a time loop. That would be fine the narrow focus meant the core clubbing and killing experience was everything I hoped it would be, but sometimes objectives don’t seem to trigger properly or some gremlin in the machine breaks the flow, and all of that glorious style falls flat like a dapperly dressed drunk trying to shimmy just a little too hard.

The scope is narrow and the execution is imperfect.

It’s still a bloody good time-troubling tactical shooter though, even if I wish it had more space to explore the world, and more variety in the tasks and locations. Think of it as a snapshot though, a malleable freeze-frame that captures one aspect of life in a particularly gleeful cyberpunk dystopia. By framing an entire world through the lens of an never-ending party, All Walls Must Fall creates a sense of claustrophobic, anarchic bliss. A final ecstasy before the flames.

As long as you’re aware of the limitations and can endure a few false steps, that’s worth the price of entry.

All Walls Must Fall is available now for Windows, Mac and Linux and is available via Steam for £7.19.

14 Comments

  1. Premium User Badge

    Aerothorn says:

    Looks like you got some broken links here! Appreciate the thoughts, though.

  2. conronc says:

    My biggest gripe about this game is it’s an environment I deeply want explored from a narrative sense and it does that on a very surface level. And I mean that about all of its constituent parts, the sex-and-drugs Berlin gay clubs, the cruising scene it flirts with, context of gay code BUT ALSO the idea of the locked Cold War environment where everyone pretends like they’re doing nothing but extensive subterfuge is at play crossed with timeline shenanigans. It’s all brilliant

    Instead you get an addictive paced shootout/puzzler which honestly I think is closer in relationship to Crypt of the Necrodancer. I think the core gameplay loop is fantastic (and I’ve run into none of the aforementioned bugs) but I still wanted more narrative out of it.

    Still a very solid game though.

    • anHorse says:

      Yeah I’d love a shadowrun style game about something as interesting and obscure as that.

    • LTK says:

      I am one of Necrodancer’s biggest fans (look for me on the daily challenge leaderboards sometime) but the timed decision element of AWMF really didn’t sit well with me. I played two missions on the default settings before starting over without the time penalty. For a tactical game like this I really need to be able to take stock of my options and plan, and the ticking down of my time resource was a major obstacle to that.

      • AmazingPotato says:

        I popped by to make exactly the same comment about the time resource in AWMF – I can’t fault its inclusion and thematic point, but it made me feel rushed and unnecessarily tense to see my time constantly hemorrhaging, when I really wanted the chance to carefully take stock of a situation.

  3. Kollega says:

    Here’s a dreadful joke that I just realized is relevant to both cyberpunk and Germany, and I feel fits the cyberpunk context just as well as the original context of Opel Manta jokes.

    Q: Why do street samurai need eight additional headlamps on their Japanese superbikes?
    A: So that they can drive while wearing sunglasses at night.

  4. DeadlyAccurate says:

    I’ve been really struggling with the game beyond the tutorial missions, and I think my mistake has been trying to avoid killing people. I was trying to play it like a sneak tactical game: get in, complete objective, get out, minimal contact. I haven’t been able to do either of the first two Normal missions because of that. I guess I should just start killing as soon as possible.

    The game is very addictive, even as I find myself wondering if there’s a way to change the difficulty level.

    • LTK says:

      Well, you didn’t make a mistake. It is indeed very difficult to complete a mission and never kill anyone, but it is quite doable to kill everyone and then unkill them after you’re safe. If that doesn’t work out, you can complete the mission by killing everyone and then go back for a do-over where you spend all your spare time resource rewinding your kills before completing the mission.

  5. Vilos Cohaagen says:

    That’s a fair review. My own personal experience meshes well with yours. Still glad I bought it though :)

  6. LTK says:

    The scope is narrow and the execution is imperfect.

    This is a perfect encapsulation. I bought this just recently and I enjoyed it for the length of one campaign, but by the time I started the second one, the mounting performance issues, glitchy objectives, trial-and-error conversation system and time-travel bugs grew beyond my ability to tolerate them.

    And I was having such a good time, too. I think you’re eventually supposed to realise that combat itself is a kind of failure already, and the challenge becomes to complete every mission non-lethally. This is made possible by the inventive (but obvious, in retrospect) mechanic of resetting missions after you’ve completed them, allowing you to tackle them with all the new temporal gadgets you’ve unlocked since.

    It was actually a great challenge to not just be the last man standing, but make it so that I never shot anyone at all. The selective rewind power is cheap enough that I can mow down a room full of enemies, slip away to a secluded spot, and rewind until it never happened. I wish the game were more polished, then I would have kept enjoying it, but as it is, it just doesn’t feel like it should have left Early Access.

  7. MrUnimport says:

    I have about an hour in the game, but I think while the presentation and setting are quite delightful, there just really isn’t that much content on display. One club is much like another, the persuasion dialogues for standard guards are all pulled from the same pool. I guess for eight bucks Canadian one could do worse, but it suffers somewhat for a lack of mechanical complexity. Also the story dialogues are quite confusing.

  8. April March says:

    A sad surmise – it seems like it’s more conservative that it seems like it would be.

    But it stays in my wishlist.

  9. JoeX111 says:

    When I drop the beat, my replays always look like janky messes of obscure camera angles and stuttery playback, never the beat-tastic Baby Driver music videos others have described.

  10. A Gentleman and a Taffer says:

    Good review, I was curious about this one, loved the idea of the turn based combat playing out in realtime, Frozen Synapse style, but with added beats.

    Somewhat share your feelings on cyberpunk, too, I really love some cyberpunky stuff (Invisible Inc and Deus Ex are possibly my 2 favourite ever games) but get really turned off by stuff like Mute and Altered Carbon, they don’t remotely appeal. Even though you could probably say the games are guiltier of just wearing the aesthetic without exploring it.

    Can’t put my finger on why. Too much of a good thing? I guess sci-fi is best when it asks “What if…?” and makes you think of futures you hadn’t yet anticipated. But Cyberpunk’s been pretty run dry of potential futures. Not to mention the fact we are living it day after day. The Corporations won and we spend half our days in digital realms we are micro-seconds from accessing wherever we are. Isn’t that what cyberpunk was about?

    Perhaps the Cyberpunk aesthetic, which is still weird and cool, just clashes with the Cyberpunk philosophies which are nowadays pretty much the norm.