If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

Mystery Steam Reviews: video games with Metacritic scores of 60 or lower

Three star wars

We don't like numbers round these parts. We're more interested in telling you whether a game is worth your time with words. One person's three star review is another's seven out of ten, so it's just better to evaluate games via text.

However, there are a lot of folks that think otherwise. They enjoy giving scores to games. And, without them, we wouldn't have a Mystery Steam Reviews this week. So, thank you, score-givers.

We've run another poll on the Rock Paper Shotgun YouTube channel for the next edition of Mystery Steam Reviews, so go and vote if you want to have a say in what the next MSR is all about.

Cover image for YouTube videoThe PC Gaming Weekspot: Gotham Knights! Life Is Strange: True Colors! Forspoken! Other Stuff!

This week, both myself and Matthew had to choose three games that have Metacritic scores of 60 or lower. You know: those games that are, at best, just above average.

If you're new around these parts, you can see a full breakdown of the rules in the Mystery Steam Reviews Rule Bible™ below. Also, remember to boast about getting all six right in the comments. And, while you're there, let us know what series/genre/theme you'd like to see added to our MSR polls.

If you like this, then you may very well enjoy this week's episode of The PC Gaming Weekspot. We chatted about Gotham Knights getting delayed and what other games may be pushed to 2021, we recapped the inaugural Square Enix Presents and the games that came from that like Life Is Strange: True Colors and Forspoken, and we brought some indie games to Show and Tell like Adios and Blind Drive.

While you're here, why not have a look at last week's episode of Mystery Steam Reviews that focused on female protagonists in video games.


For those not in the know, or who need a refresher.

Colm and Matthew both bring three Steam reviews to the MSR arena (yes, arena), but they omit the name of the game each review is for. Their opponent must correctly guess the name of that game, including any numbers or subtitles. However, there is some leeway for things such as "Complete Edition" or "Definitive Edition." One correct answer = one point.

While both combatants have 90 seconds on each Mystery Steam Review, they also have help in the form of three lifelines. These can be used at any stage during battle, and pause the 90-second timer. Each lifeline can only be used once.

Question allows whoever is in the hot seat to ask a simple yes or no question, as long as the question isn’t, “is the name of the game [insert name of the game here]?". When Second Opinion is used, the man in the warm chair will get to hear a second Steam review of the same game. And when Genre is activated, the genre of the game is revealed to the man with the fiery arse.

Rock Paper Shotgun is the home of PC gaming

Sign in and join us on our journey to discover strange and compelling PC games.

Related topics
About the Author
Colm Ahern avatar

Colm Ahern

Former Video Producer

Sonic the Hedgehog apologist and video maker. It's pronounced "Cull-um".