If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

Dead Space: Dead In the Water? 

Okay, that's just going for the fancy pun-based headline as is RPS' wont - it's not dead, dead. But I've been thinking about EA's recently released Dead Space's chances, and this post was prompted by Yahtzee's Zero Punctuation annihilation of it - which I'll embed beneath the cut. He takes it apart - which is his wont, obviously - but it's a game that seems to be slipping past everyone's attention. Which seems somewhat odd. I mean, big-budget, hyper-slick action/horror game. It's not exactly Dwarf Fortress.

I'm saying "wont" a lot in this post.

Anyway, here's Yahtzee having a little ramble.

In passing, there's a name for people who move from England to Australia: Criminals. We've got our eyes on you, Croshaw.

Where was I? Dead Space. Well, it's too early to really talk about sales, but looking at the English weekly charts doesn't show a game that's dominating in the way which you expect a EA-backed game to do. It's managed to hit Top 10 in all single formats, but now by its second week is already out of the all-format charts. Reviews have been favourable across all formats - currently 86% on the PC over at Metacritics - and that's very close to its user-ratings. In other words, it's out, people like it and... well, is that enough?

I admit, I haven't played it yet. Jim has, and dug it. Why haven't I played it? Well, it's the reason why I suspect that it hasn't done the business you presume EA thought it would do. It's a ludicrously busy time of year. When I'm struggling to fit in Far Cry 2, Fall Out 3 and Left 4 Dead, do I really have time for a space-horror game that's getting really good but not great reviews? Well, I wish I did, but I don't.

And I think that's what's the problem - Dead Space seems to be hypercompetent and slick. But what it doesn't seem to be is innovative. And at this time of year, selling a new creation without some obvious big hook to attract people's attention... well, that's hard. You suspect it may have done better in February, which is a traditional time to debut new IPs you don't want lost in the Christmas melee.

Which leads me to the real point of the post. I'd had a few people mail us and ask us if we could do something about Dead Space, because they really liked it and thought it worth hyping up. I wanted to provide a place both for people who've played the game to have a little chat and for those who didn't take the dive to say why.

I mean, is it the fact it uses the EA standard DRM? The lack of a PC Demo? Or just too busy?

About the Author

Support Rock Paper Shotgun

Subscribe and get access to supporter-only articles, an ad-free reading experience, free gifts, and game discounts. Your support helps us create more great writing about PC games.

See more information


More News

Latest Articles

Supporters Only

Rock Paper Shotgun logo

We've been talking, and we think that you should wear clothes

Total coincidence, but we sell some clothes

Rock Paper Shotgun Merch